|
THE OFFICIAL WEBPAGE OF ROBERT D. WEST |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Trojan in Twilight The final days of the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant
The Trojan Nuclear Power Plant in its final days, a week from the Cooling Tower's implosion.
The Trojan Nuclear Power Plant has been a northwest landmark since it was built in the 1970s. I had been intending to put up a page about it ever since writing the PLACES - Rainier, Oregon page about my hometown. Trojan had existed for my entire life, and when Portland General Electric announced in late 2005 that the plant would soon be demolished, I knew I had to work fast to create the page I simply had to have.
The photos on this page were taken on April 22, 2006 and May 13, 2006, except for the pictures taken the day of the cooling tower implosion: May 21, 2006. Most were taken with my digital camera, except for a few taken on film to take advantage of my Pentax Spotmatic's superior lens selection and responsiveness. This page is the first to primarily use pictures taken with my Canon PowerShot A520 digital camera.
My main sources of information included Portland General Electric's website, Wikipedia's article about the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant, NukeWorker.com, The Virtual Nuclear Tourist, the Trojan Wetlands page, Howstuffworks.com, articles from The Daily News, The Clatskanie Chief, The Columbia County News/Advertiser, The Columbian, The Oregonian and The Statesman-Journal and special thanks to Tim Keller, a PGE employee who worked at Trojan for information about the site not available elsewhere. I would also like to thank Gene Davis, from whose property my dad and I watched the implosion of the cooling tower.
History of the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant
In 1967, Portland General Electric selected the site for a new power plant in the state of Oregon. The 634-acre site was on the banks of the Columbia River in Columbia County, 42 miles north of Portland, between the small towns of Prescott and Goble, and 4 miles from the town of Rainier. Three miles away, on the Washington side of the river, was the town of Kalama.
This site held an ancient Native American burial ground and was noted by Meriwether Lewis and William Clark as native fishing grounds as they sailed down the Columbia River. More recently, the site had been producing explosives: gun powder and dynamite for the Trojan Powder Works. This previous tenant would unknowingly lend its name to the to the new, modern facility that would rise here in its place: the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant.
I could explain in detail how a nuclear power plant works, but Howstuffworks.com already did. How Nuclear Power Plants Work at Howstuffworks.com
Click here for more about the Trojan Wetlands.
Area Map
Despite the fact that nuclear power plants generate far less pollution than coal or oil plants, and that the average person is exposed to more radiation from everyday sources than they would be from living near a nuclear power plant, Trojan was never popular with environmentalist groups, and a number of protests, led by Lloyd Marbet, were staged at the entrance to the site, often resulting in protestors being arrested. Trojan was closed for nine months in 1978, to correct errors made during construction, and to improve the plant's resistance to potential earthquakes caused by a previously unknown fault line. In 1979, the motion picture The China Syndrome was released, unrealistically depicting a fictional nuclear power plant suffering a reactor meltdown & releasing molten nuclear fuel into the earth. (TRIVIA: The control room of the power plant in The China Syndrome was actually based off of Trojan's control room, which the creators of the movie visited.) On March 28, 1979, 12 days after the release of The China Syndrome, the accident at the Three Mile Island Nuclear Power Plant in Pennsylvania occurred. Although the Three Mile Island incident actually proved that the fictional events depicted in The China Syndrome were impossible, the movie benefited from the news coverage of Three Mile Island. All of these factors led to Oregon voters approving a ban on the construction of new nuclear power plants in the state in 1980.
Click here to see the Nuclear Energy Institute's Critique of The China Syndrome.
Though Oregon's voters had decided they didn't want any new nuclear plants, the voters never closed Trojan. Attempts by Marbet and other environmental activists to close Trojan were defeated by the voters in 1986, 1990 and 1992. Portland General Electric spent over $5 million to defeat the 1992 ballot measure, still the most expensive ballot measure campaign in Oregon state history. On November 9, 1992, one week after the ballot measure was defeated in the general election, a steam generator tube leak forced Trojan to shut down. Portland General Electric determined that the cost to fully repair the plant was not economical in comparison to electricity generated from other sources (most, if not all, of Trojan's electricity was sold to markets in California; Oregon's own needs were being met mostly by hydroelectric dams) and announced on January 4, 1993 that Trojan would remain shut down permanently, and all nuclear fuel was removed from the reactor and placed in the spent fuel storage pool. After fighting hard to keep the plant open, PGE would willingly close it less than halfway through its anticipated lifespan. In May 1993, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission changed PGE's license for Trojan to a possession-only license, officially ending the plant's operation.
With Trojan closed for good, the economy of the surrounding area would suffer, especially in nearby Rainier. Not only was Rainier the home to many Trojan employees who would now be forced to find work elsewhere, but the city's police department, fire department and school district had been supported largely by the tax revenue from the plant. In the coming years, the police department would be reduced to buying used police cars, the fire department would combine with the fire department in nearby St. Helens to be able to replace aging equipment, and the school district would close three schools, consolidating entirely into the Hudson Park Elementary & Rainier High School built when Trojan first opened in the 1970s.
How long did Trojan operate?
Trojan operated for about 17 years. The exact length of Trojan's operation depends on what dates are used for the beginning and end of operation.
Possible Start Dates December 15, 1975: Reactor achieves first criticality May 20, 1976: Commercial operation begins
Possible End Dates November 9, 1992: Plant shuts down January 4, 1993: PGE announces plant will not restart May 1993: License changed to possession-only
Depending on how you calculate it, the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant operated anywhere from about 16.5 years to 17.5 years. Commercial operation lasted about 16.5 years, while the reactor was in operation for just over a month short of 17 years. The plant's license for commercial operation was effective for almost exactly 17 years.
Trojan Decommissioning
As the local economy suffered, PGE moved forward in decommissioning Trojan. While waiting for the NRC to approve the complete decommissioning plan, PGE removed Trojan's four steam generators and pressurizer in November 1995. This was known as the Large Component Removal Project. The steam generators were each 14.5 feet in diameter and 68 feet long. The pressurizer was 8.5 feet in diameter and 53 feet long. These items were transported by barge up the Columbia River to the Department of Energy's low-level nuclear waste disposal facility at Hanford near Richland, Washington. In April 1996, the NRC approved PGE's complete decommissioning plan. The total cost of decommissioning Trojan was estimated at $429 million.
Photos of the reactor vessel being moved can be found here. There are a few in here too.
When Trojan closed, a total of 781 spent fuel rod assemblies were in the spent fuel storage pool. Eventually, these highly radioactive fuel rods are to be moved to the future Federal Nuclear Waste Repository, which is expected to be established at Yucca Mountain in Nevada. However, these rods had to be removed from the spent fuel pool to complete decommissioning. To provide a secure place to store these rods, PGE built a thick concrete pad measuring 170' x 105' at the northeast corner of the Trojan site, about 900 feet north of the cooling tower, surrounded with two sets of barbed-wire fences, floodlights and full security monitoring. This is the Independent Spent Fuel Storage Installation (ISFSI), or dry cask storage facility. Beginning in December 2002, the spent fuel rods were removed from the spent fuel pool and loaded into welded stainless steel canisters. The canisters were then placed into one of 34 concrete casks with 29-inch thick walls, and moved to the ISFSI. Transfer of the spent fuel rods to the ISFSI was completed in September 2003.
By October 2004, PGE had completed the decommissioning plan and requested that the State of Oregon release the site for unrestricted use. The Final Site Survey was completed in December 2004, and a request for license termination was submitted to the NRC. In April 2005, the Oregon Energy Facility Siting Council determined that the site met the criteria for unrestricted use, and on May 23, 2005, the NRC terminated Trojan's license, releasing the Trojan site for unrestricted use. Decommissioning was officially complete, and demolition of the power plant's buildings could begin. Demolition of the Turbine Building, Control Building, Auxiliary Building and Fuel Building, collectively known as the Power Block, began in March 2006 and will be completed in 2007. The 499-foot Cooling Tower was demolished by implosion at 7am on May 21, 2006, 30 years and one day after Trojan began commercial operation. It was the first cooling tower to be imploded in the United States and the largest yet imploded in the world. The dome-shaped Containment Building is scheduled for demolition in 2008.
Because of the ISFSI, the Trojan site is not completely free of nuclear material, and PGE will maintain a presence there for many years to come. The ISFSI operates under a separate license from the NRC. Because there is still no federal nuclear waste depository, the first shipment from the Trojan ISFSI is not expected until at least 2013, and full decommissioning of the ISFSI is not expected until 2024. PGE still maintains an electrical switching station at Trojan. This station has recently been expanded with an additional line to serve the new 400-megawatt power plant at Port Westward, about 15 miles from Trojan. In addition, although PGE's attempts to donate Trojan Park to the State of Oregon or Columbia County have failed, PGE continues to maintain the park and keep it open to the general public.
The Simpsons Connection
A side note about the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant is the widespread belief that it directly inspired the fictional Springfield Nuclear Power Plant, Homer Simpson's place of employment on The Simpsons. This belief stems from the fact that Simpsons creator Matt Groening is a native of Portland, and many of the characters are named after streets in Portland (such as Ned Flanders, Reverend Lovejoy, Mayor Quimby & Sideshow Bob Terwilliger) or other places in Oregon (like, say, Rainier Wolfcastle). Matt Groening has never confirmed this, and in 2006, as Trojan's cooling tower was being prepared for demolition, Groening's publicist made a statement that the Springfield Nuclear Power Plant was not based on any particular real power plant. Also, the Springfield power plant is depicted with two reactors and two cooling towers, where Trojan has only one of each. However, it is still possible that even if Trojan was not the basis for the Springfield plant, the fact that Trojan existed and was in the news around the time Groening created The Simpsons may have at least given Groening the idea.
Coincidentally, the date that the cooling tower was imploded, Sunday, May 21, 2006, was also the air date of the of the 17th season finale of The Simpsons. The Trojan Nuclear Power Plant had operated for about 17 years.
Views of the Trojan Nuclear Power Plant
From the Kalama Sportsmen's Club Boat Launch
The closest a person can get to Trojan in the State of Washington is the boat launch of the Kalama Sportsmen's Club. This is also the best view of the Containment Building short of being on a boat. From here, you can clearly see the opening in the Containment Building through which the reactor vessel was removed in 1999 for transport to Hanford. You can also see the Fuel Building and the back side of the Turbine Building, both under demolition. And, of course, there's the Cooling Tower, waiting out its days.
The panorama from this spot is impressive.
From here there is also a view of the dock south of the cooling tower. When the reactor was removed from the plant it was loaded onto the barge at this dock on August 6, 1999. There is also a small rocky island with a beacon on it to warn ships about Coffin Rock, which juts out into the Columbia River just south of the power plant.
From Graham Road at U.S. Highway 30
Along U.S. Highway 30
Heading south from Graham Road on Highway 30, the rest of the power plant site comes into view. This would be a great viewpoint if it wasn't for the traffic of the highway being literally a few feet away. Not much shoulder on the highway here. Great panorama though.
There is spot to pull off the highway close to this spot, where an informational sign explains about the Whistling Swans, for whom these wetlands are a winter habitat, though when I took these pictures, the swans had already migrated north for the summer.
THE WHISTLING SWAN These are the common native swan of North America. Their nesting grounds are on lowland lakes along the arctic coasts of Alaska and Canada. In early autumn they migrate south to both U.S. coasts to spend the winter in a warmer climate. These large white birds are found in this area from November to March. Except for the rare Trumpeter, the Whistling Swan is the largest wild fowl in Oregon. It has a wing spread of approximately 7 ft. and a weight of 12 to 19 lbs. In Oregon they are provided complete year around protection, and hunting them is not permitted.
Trojan Artwork
This mural cannot be original to the mall, as the mall predates the construction of Trojan be several years. It seems this was added around the time of Trojan's construction. There are a couple of interesting aspects to this mural. First, although the mural was placed in Washington, it depicts the plant as viewed from along U.S. Highway 30 in Oregon instead of as viewed from Kalama, Washington as might be expected. Second, some parts of the mural are quite accurate, such as the locations of the lights on the Cooling Tower, and the general layout of windows on the Turbine Building, while other parts, like the windows depicted in the dome of the Containment Building, are significant errors. There is also a construction crane in the background, and the Administration Building is conspicuously absent, suggesting this painting was made while the plant was still under construction in the early 1970s.
The mural remained in place through late 2005, but by 2006 RiteAid had renovated that side of the building to install a drive-up window and generally "update" the exterior, and the Pay 'N Save signage, including the Trojan mural, were no longer visible. I don't know if the mural is still in place behind the new exterior, or if it was removed and taken somewhere else. Either way, it managed to remain in place almost as long as the real Trojan.
Tour of the Trojan Grounds
Trojan Site Map
Main Entrance
I found this picture of the original sign on this page.
Here is the view of the Cooling Tower from the Main Entrance to the Trojan Site.
Visitors Information Center
Nukeworker.com has a photo of the back of the Visitors Information Center here.
Reflection Lake
The Visitors Information Center sat on the edge of the 26-acre rectangular Reflection Lake. Here is the view of the power plant from where the Visitors Information Center was. The panorama of the Reflection Lake is quite nice.
Visitor Viewing Platform
Heliport
Visitors Information Center Parking Lot
Trojan used a number of unusual, and possibly unique, light fixtures outside the buildings, and the abandoned Visitors Information Center parking lot showcases several of them. The dome-shape seems to be the common theme, probably mimicking the shape of the Containment Building which held the nuclear reactor. First are the concrete bollards/lights. At the bus parking area, concrete parking lot lights alternate with plain concrete bollards. The concrete lights also lined the perimeter of the parking lot. The low, metal light was used at islands in the parking lot and on the viewing platform. The taller metal light was used at corners of islands. A few of the metal lights have been decapitated by vandals. One still has the remains of a light bulb in place!
Spotlights
Driveway
Trojan Park Recreation Lake
Trojan Park's 29-acre Recreation Lake is a popular gathering place for domesticated geese and ducks. Some of them are very domesticated, and don't even flinch around people. In fact they seem to expect to be fed. They didn't even seem to mind the kids in the little toy car.
When I took these pictures, Trojan Park was not officially open yet. The park does not technically open until Memorial Day, and the park's parking lot was gated off with a sign that made that perfectly clear. But, that doesn't stop people from parking wherever they can to enjoy PGE's beautiful park, whether its open or not. Here's a panorama of the Reflecting Lake from the other direction. The building on the right edge is the next stop on the tour.
Training Building
There are two sides to the Training Building that could be considered the front. This is the first one, the south side, and is really the more obvious one. The Training Building is not an original Trojan building; it was built in the late 1980s. Its original function should be obvious from the name. It didn't get to serve in its intended service for very long before the plant closed down, though it did get some further use by Concordia University for some outreach courses. There is a large parking lot on the east side of the Training Building.
Here is the east side of the Training Building, and while it may not have technically been the front of the building, the doors on this side probably got the most use. Even though this building was added later, the lights along the sidewalk carry on the dome-shaped theme from elsewhere on the site. Notice that the Training Building actually wraps around a courtyard, which is accessible from the east side, though the canopy almost makes it possible to not even notice the courtyard.
Inside the courtyard. The trees seem to be doing well on their own. The Cooling Tower is reflected in the glass of the Training Building, and as seen directly from inside the courtyard. Incidentally, that last picture is the 2000th picture taken with my digital camera.
The Training Building even featured uniquely decorated trash cans, and they are still in place in 2006. I really like the larger one, though the small one has a charm all its own as well.
As the view through the windows shows, the Training Building has most recently become a warehouse for paperwork. Boxes and boxes on pallets fill the lobby atrium, many of them covered in plastic, apparently anticipating a long stay. More boxes line the hallways.
Training Building Parking Lot
These old Army surplus trucks were found in the Training Building parking lot a week before the Cooling Tower implosion. They weren't there a few weeks earlier. They are owned by International Line Builders, Inc., and look like they've seen a lot of duty in their many years.
Trojan Park Entrance
Main Gate
This is the main gate leading into the actual power plant area. The railroad tracks in front of the gate are the Portland & Western Railroad's line from Portland to Astoria. That is not just a spur; it is a main track cutting through the Trojan property. This route was originally built by the Astoria & Columbia River Railroad, opening for service in 1898. The sign warning vehicles not to block the tracks while waiting for the gate to open is amusing, as it shows an old steam locomotive colliding with a 1980s-era truck, and both images look like computer clip-art. There are two guard houses; one at the gate, and one a little further up the road.
Before we look at the actual power plant though, there's one more important building outside the gate.
Administration Building
At the north end of the Trojan site is PGE's old Administration Building. While Trojan was still in operation, this large building was full of offices for Trojan employees. When the plant closed in 1993, the building was vacated. Undoubtedly a building PGE would have liked to lease out to tenants, the building's main use since has been to store papers during Enron's ownership of PGE.
Administration Building Parking Lot
Security Entrance
Trojan Central
Beyond the Security Entrance lies this building, called Trojan Central. Trojan Central is not an original Trojan building; it, like the Training Building, was added in the late 1980s. After the plant closed in 1993, operations were consolidated in Trojan Central, allowing the Administration Building to be vacated, probably in the hopes that it could be leased out to some other tenant. Trojan Central remained occupied until 2005, when the plant's decommissioning was completed. Notice that the light fixtures at Trojan Central do not carry on the dome-shaped theme found outside the fence.
Turbine Building
The demolition of the Power Block is scheduled to be completed in 2007, leaving the Containment Building standing alone until its demolition in 2008.
Cooling Tower
The most dominant feature by far on the Trojan site was the cooling tower. For some reason, many people don't understand the function of a cooling tower, and some even think that the tower is the power plant itself, so I will try to give an explanation of what a cooling tower is and what it does.
Most power plants, including those that burn coal, oil and natural gas as well as nuclear plants, simply heat water to produce steam which is used to turn a steam turbine connected to a generator. This steam is then cooled in condensers back into water to be reheated. The condenser itself is cooled by water from a separate supply, which in turn is cooled in a cooling tower and cycled back through the condenser. In some cases, these cooling towers are largely mechanical in nature, which keeps the size down in relation to the rest of the power plant, but requires more electricity. The other option is to use a much larger natural draft cooling tower. While the general public most often associates these towers with nuclear power plants, they can be found in other applications, including power plants using other fuels, and some nuclear plants use mechanical draft cooling towers instead of natural draft.
Trojan used a 499-foot hyperbolic natural draft cooling tower to cool the water for the condensers. A natural draft cooling tower operates entirely on the basic principle that air rises as it heats up. Though a natural draft cooling tower is by far the most visually impressive component of a nuclear power plant, because there is two completely separate systems between the nuclear reactor in the Containment Building and the cooling water of the condensers, the cooling tower is never exposed to any nuclear radiation or radioactive material.
The Virtual Nuclear Tourist has a good general explanation of Cooling Towers.
For more information on how a nuclear power plant generates electricity, Click Here.
Trojan's cooling tower was completed in May 1972, and consisted of 41,000 tons of concrete and steel. The tower's hyperbolic shape was designed to provide structural strength and speed vertical airflow. The diameter at the base measured 385 feet and the walls were 45 inches thick. At the top of the 499-foot height, the diameter was 250 feet, and the walls were 18 inches thick. At the tower's narrowest point, about 2/3 of the way up, the diameter was 232 feet and the walls were 10 inches thick.
The cooling tower was 499 feet tall; if it were any taller, it would have had to be painted with red & white stripes. As it was, the tower had to have a number of lights in place. Red lights were placed at the top of the tower and at 3 other elevations spaced equally up the side of the tower. At each elevation, a light faced in each direction. Starting at the bottom, the red lights at the first and third row were on constantly. The red lights on the other two levels (the middle of the tower and the top) oscillated on and off, all at the same time, at a period of about every three seconds. Additionally, white strobes were also mounted at the top of the tower, halfway between the red lights around the perimeter. The white strobes flashed about 40 times a minute, though they did not seem to be synchronized with the red lights in any way.
The cooling tower would have been the tallest building in Oregon when completed in May 1972, however Portland's 546-foot First National Bank Tower (now Wells Fargo Center) was completed the same month. Since then, Portland's 536-foot U.S. Bancorp Tower and 509-foot KOIN Center have also topped the cooling tower's height. The following table shows how Trojan's cooling tower compared to other tall structures locally and around the world.
|